We make unique sweets into perfect treats!
Whatever your favorite, we can make it!! Pies in Disguise specializes in unique, pies that taste just like your favorite snack, be it candy, cereal, cookies, etc.
If you can think it, we can make it!
- Seasonal 7 products
- All Desserts 23 products
- Fruit & Nut Themed 14 products
- Candy Themed 9 products
- Cereal Themed 2 products
- Gift Cards 1 products
-
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $55.00
- Regular price
-
- Sale price
- $55.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Strawberry Lemon Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$75.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
‘I Love You’ Cake
- Regular price
- From $75.00
- Regular price
-
$85.00 - Sale price
- From $75.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
German Chocolate Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $65.00
- Regular price
-
- Sale price
- $65.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Nutella / Ferrero Roché Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $75.00
- Regular price
-
$90.00 - Sale price
- $75.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Red Velvet Dream Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$85.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
Showing 6 of 7 products on Seasonal collection
-
Aunt Mert's Turtle Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $55.00
- Regular price
-
$0.00 - Sale price
- $55.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Mama Orlene's Banana Pudding Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $30.00
- Regular price
-
$45.00 - Sale price
- $30.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Red Velvet Dream Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$85.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Baked Strawberry Lattice Pie
- Regular price
- $45.00
- Regular price
-
$0.00 - Sale price
- $45.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $50.00
- Regular price
-
$0.00 - Sale price
- $50.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Louise’s Caramel Apple Walnut Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$75.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
Showing 6 of 23 products on All Desserts collection
-
‘I Love You’ Cake
- Regular price
- From $75.00
- Regular price
-
$85.00 - Sale price
- From $75.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Strawberry Lemon Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$75.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Pineapple Upside Down Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$65.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Red Velvet Dream Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$85.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Louise’s Caramel Apple Walnut Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$75.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Peach Cinnamon Streusel Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$75.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
Showing 6 of 14 products on Fruit & Nut Themed collection
-
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $55.00
- Regular price
-
- Sale price
- $55.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
‘I Love You’ Cake
- Regular price
- From $75.00
- Regular price
-
$85.00 - Sale price
- From $75.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
German Chocolate Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $65.00
- Regular price
-
- Sale price
- $65.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Nutella / Ferrero Roché Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $75.00
- Regular price
-
$90.00 - Sale price
- $75.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$75.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Cookie Brownie Explosion
- Regular price
- $65.00
- Regular price
-
- Sale price
- $65.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
Showing 6 of 9 products on Candy Themed collection
-
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $50.00
- Regular price
-
$0.00 - Sale price
- $50.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Unicorn Cheesecake 🦄✨
- Regular price
- From $50.00
- Regular price
-
- Sale price
- From $50.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
-
Pies in Disguise Gift Card
- Regular price
- From $10.00
- Regular price
-
- Sale price
- From $10.00
- Unit price
- per
Sold Out
Featured product
Red Velvet Dream Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $60.00
- Regular price
-
$85.00 - Sale price
- $60.00
- Unit price
- per
We take two classic favorites and combine them to make an amazingly, delicious dessert! This cheesecake features an Oreo cookie crust with red velvet cheesecake filling and topped with nuts, mini chocolate chips and cream cheese icing!
NOTE: This item can be made with or without nuts and/or with or without chocolate chips.
Featured product
Nutella / Ferrero Roché Cheesecake
- Regular price
- $75.00
- Regular price
-
$90.00 - Sale price
- $75.00
- Unit price
- per
Our decadent Chocolate Truffle Cheesecake aka The “Scrumdiddlyuptious” is made with over 2 lbs of Nutella filling & ganache, a homemade chocolate whipped cream, and delicious Ferrero Rocher chocolates on an OREO chocolate crust